Elyria’s Auto Body Experts

Elyria, Ohio USASince 1925, Murphy Bros. Auto Body has helped Lorain County drivers make their cars look like new again, with quality work from our shop in Downtown Elyria:

  • Collision and Accident Repair
  • Automotive Painting
  • Paintless Dent Removal
  • Damage Assessment and Estimates
  • Insurance Claims Assistance
  • Car Rentals and On Site Mechanical
  • Over 90 Years of Service
  • The Highest Standards in Industry
  • Quality and Attention to Detail
  • Lifetime Warranty on Workmanship

 
Cromax Paint Color Matching System

About Murphy Bros.

Our Commitment

We will do everything we can to make sure every customer has a positive experience at Murphy Bros. We work to reduce the hassle after a collision; we consider this an important part of our service. We focus on quality, flexibility, and being a convenient one-stop shop.

Paul and Tony LaGrotteria
Paul and Tony LaGrotteria

Family Owned & Operated

Our family-owned and operated auto body business offers the highest quality and safest collision repairs available anywhere in Northeast Ohio. Our success comes from over 90 years of building and maintaining relationships with each one of our customers.

Murphy Bros. Auto Body was established in 1925. In 1983, the business was purchased by Joe LaGrotteria Sr. It is now owned and operated by Joe’s two sons, Paul and Tony LaGrotteria, and grandson Joey LaGrotteria III.

A car in the Murphy Bros. Auto Body paint booth

Our Collision Repair Process

AxaltaAt Murphy Bros., we use the best tools and systems to do the job right. We have created standard operating procedures for every phase of the collision repair process, to ensure that each vehicle is uniformly and properly repaired. Each of our qualified technicians are trained on these SOPs and must pass a certification test annually. Accountability and consistency are key.

Chief Laser LockThese standardized procedures ensure that we are able to reduce overall costs by reducing the amount of re-work that occurs. Our motto: DO IT RIGHT THE FIRST TIME!

We continue tech training based on direct feedback from our customers as well. We obtain this feedback through responses to customer surveys, which we review weekly to determine how we can continue to meet and exceed our customers’ needs.

CromaxFinally, through the Performance Alliance Network, we use software to document the requirements of our direct repair programs. This software enables us to create, customize and implement the training and online testing necessary to diligently apply DRP claims processing and cost control procedures. In turn, this allows us to provide timely and efficient service to our customers and the insurance company.

Collision Repair Work

Photos of in-process repairs and painting at Murphy Bros. Auto Body:


Click any thumbnail to see a larger image.

 
Some before-and-after photos of body and paint work performed by Murphy Bros. Auto Body:

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: HOW DO I GET AN ESTIMATE ON MY VEHICLE?
We are open for estimates Monday through Friday from 8:00 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. No appointment is needed.

Q: ARE YOU A DIRECT REPAIR SHOP FOR INSURANCE?
Yes, we are a direct repair shop for many different insurance companies. By working directly with these insurance companies, the claims process goes more smoothly. We write the estimates per the insurance company guidelines, take photos, schedule the work, and coordinate a rental car.

Q: WHAT KIND OF WARRANTY DO YOU OFFER?
We provide a lifetime warranty on all our auto body workmanship for as long as you own the vehicle. Of course, this does not cover normal wear and tear nor damage from improper maintenance, neglect or abuse.

Q: HOW DO I GET ALTERNATE TRANSPORTATION?
We will help you arrange for a rental car, either through our Murphy Bros fleet or from a major rental company.

Q: WHAT IF MY CAR NEEDS TOWED?
Call us and we can arrange a truck to get it. If you have your own towing arrangements just tell the driver to bring it to Murphy Bros. Auto Body. If you have a police tow, you may need to get a police release to get it towed to us. Call us and we can guide you through this.

Q: WHAT IF MY CAR NEEDS MECHANICAL REPAIR?
On site, we have an independent mechanical repair shop that can meet any of your needs — from oil changes to engine changes!

Q: HOW MANY ESTIMATES DO I NEED TO GET?
You are only required to get one estimate in the State of Ohio, per the Ohio Insurance Commission. Some insurance companies will try strongly try to get YOU to go to one of their direct-owned repair shops. However, YOU have the right to go where YOU decide to have the repairs done. After all, it is YOUR car!

Old Fashioned Parts Bin at Murphy Bros. Auto Body Elyria Ohio

Q: HOW LONG WILL THE REPAIRS TAKE?
We will give you an approximate completion date when you are scheduled for repairs. This can change due to part availability and or hidden damage.

Q: HOW SHOULD I CHOOSE A REPAIR FACILITY?
The best way to choose a body shop is to ask family and friends, co-workers and your insurance agent. We take pride in providing the highest quality repair available. We have been family owned and operated since 1925. Our technicians have over 150 years of combined experience. We are I-CAR Platinum certified.

Q: WHAT IF I HAVE A SMALL DOOR DENT & DINGS?
We offer paintless dent repair on site with trained techs. Stop in for a quick estimate for free.

Q: WHICH INSURANCE COMPANIES DO YOU WORK WITH?
All of them!

Q: WHAT IS A DEDUCTIBLE?
A deductible is the amount that the insured agrees to pay first. Then the insurance company picks up the rest. Murphy Bros does not accept credit cards for the deductible payment. Normally a personal check or cash is just fine.

Q: WILL MY CAR BE CLEAN WHEN I PICK IT UP?
Yes, we vacuum the inside, wash the vehicle and then polish the freshly painted repair.

Q: DO YOU WORK SATURDAY HOURS?
Sorry, on Saturdays we spend time with the family, play golf, bike.